Self-Directed IRAs: How Retirement Capital Can Invest in Private Real Estate and Alternative Investments

For most investors, retirement accounts follow a familiar script. Contributions go in, a short menu of stocks, bonds, and mutual funds is offered, and the balance rises and falls with the public markets. Yet many investors never learn that the menu is set by the account provider, not by the law.

According to Mat Sorensen, there is roughly $49 trillion sitting in U.S. retirement accounts. Most of it is invested only in publicly traded assets, not because the rules require it, but because that is what most custodians offer. For accredited investors, financial advisors, and family offices exploring private real estate and alternative investments, that distinction opens a much larger set of options.

In Episode 2 of Wealth Unfiltered’s Year-End Tax Series, host Samantha Parrinello sat down with Mat Sorensen, attorney and CEO of Directed IRA and Directed Trust Company, to explain how self-directed retirement accounts work. Sorensen has focused on self-directed IRAs since 2006 and wrote The Self-Directed IRA Handbook, which he notes is the required textbook for the industry’s self-directed professional credential.

His perspective offers a practical framework for using retirement capital to invest in private real estate, private funds, and operating businesses, without running into the tax traps that catch unprepared investors.

Watch the full episode of Wealth Unfiltered with Mat Sorensen on YouTube.

Why Self-Directed IRAs Are Gaining Attention From Accredited Investors

Sorensen’s path into the field began with a mistake. In 2006, a client asked whether he could buy real estate with his IRA. Sorensen told him no, then researched the question and discovered he was wrong.

That moment revealed a gap. Retirement accounts held trillions of dollars, real estate was one of the most trusted wealth-building assets, and almost no one had become the expert connecting the two. Sorensen set out to fill that role, first as a tax attorney and author, and later as a custodian.

In 2018, frustrated by the custodians his legal clients were using, he co-founded Directed IRA. The company now reports roughly $4 billion in assets, four appearances on the Inc. 5000 list, and between 500 and 1,000 new accounts opened every month. Clients use those accounts to invest in everything from a duplex down the street to real estate funds, private equity, venture deals, and small businesses.

Sorensen was clear that his goal is not to steer investors toward any particular asset.

“At the core of a self-directed retirement account, the core thesis to me is let your retirement account invest in the best investment asset, period. Not the best publicly traded asset.”

How Self-Directed IRAs Differ From Traditional Retirement Accounts

A self-directed IRA is not a separate type of account. A Roth IRA at Directed IRA is still a Roth IRA, just as a SEP IRA held with a self-directed custodian is still a SEP IRA. The difference lies with the provider.

Custodians decide what an account can hold. Most broker-dealers allow only the products they sell. When an investor calls a large brokerage and is told an IRA cannot buy real estate, that limit belongs to the provider, not the IRS.

Sorensen illustrated the point with a piece of history. When IRAs launched in the 1970s, banks were the first providers, so the most popular IRA investment was the certificate of deposit. Broker-dealers later entered the market, and stocks and mutual funds took over. Today, as investors learn more about private markets, a growing share are directing a portion of their retirement capital toward alternative investments.

How to Move Retirement Funds Into a Self-Directed IRA

The first step is opening an account with a custodian that permits private assets. From there, the process depends on where the money sits today.

For existing IRAs, the move is usually simple. According to Sorensen, about $19 trillion of U.S. retirement savings already sits in IRAs, compared with about $14 trillion in 401(k)s. An investor with $400,000 in a traditional IRA can transfer all or part of it to a self-directed traditional IRA with no tax and no penalty, much like moving from one brokerage to another.

Employer plans follow different rules:

  • Former employer plans. Once an investor leaves the company, an old 401(k) or 403(b) can generally be rolled over to an IRA, including a self-directed IRA.
  • Current employer plans. While still employed, funds are usually restricted. Many plans allow rollovers once the participant reaches the plan’s retirement age, often 55 or 59½, and some permit in-service rollovers earlier.

When an IRA LLC Makes Sense, and When It Does Not

One of the most common questions Sorensen hears is whether investors need to form an LLC inside their IRA. The answer depends on how the capital will be deployed.

For investors placing retirement funds into a private real estate fund, the IRA can typically invest directly. The fund is already an entity with a manager running it, and an added LLC creates cost and complexity without much benefit. Sorensen has invested his own IRA in private funds this way.

The IRA LLC structure, sometimes called a checkbook control IRA, becomes useful for investors doing their own deals. Sorensen’s first IRA investment was a three-bedroom rental in Indianapolis. His IRA owned 100% of a newly formed LLC, he served as its manager, and the LLC held its own bank account, bought the property, collected rent, and paid expenses.

That structure offered convenience and a layer of liability protection, since a claim tied to the property could not reach the IRA or Sorensen personally. Because a single-member IRA LLC is a disregarded entity for tax purposes, it neither helps nor hurts the account’s tax position.

Other variations exist. Spouses, or one investor’s Roth and traditional accounts, can combine into one LLC with ownership split by dollars contributed. That entity is taxed as a partnership, files a return, and passes income through to each IRA.

“Once you get into this, it’s not like it’s rocket science. It’s more like a board game. Just understanding the moves and what you can and can’t do.”

His rule of thumb is simple. For roughly nine out of ten investors putting money into a private fund, the LLC is unnecessary.

What a Self-Directed IRA Cannot Invest In: Prohibited Assets and Prohibited Transactions

The list of assets an IRA cannot hold is short. Sorensen pointed to three categories: life insurance, collectibles, and S corporation stock. IRAs can own LLCs, C corporations, and limited partnerships, but they do not qualify as S corporation shareholders.

Collectibles were restricted after early abuse, such as retirement accounts buying art, wine, or classic cars that owners enjoyed personally. Congress carved out certain precious metals, so an IRA can hold physical gold, silver, platinum, and palladium if it is stored properly by an approved depository.

The more important limit concerns who the IRA transacts with, not what it buys. Under the prohibited transaction rules, an IRA cannot buy from, sell to, or otherwise deal with disqualified persons. These include the account owner, a spouse, children, and parents.

Congress designed the rule to stop investors from shifting appreciated assets into tax-advantaged accounts at a discount. In practice, that means:

  • An IRA cannot buy a property the owner already holds personally.
  • An IRA cannot sell a property to the owner or a family member.
  • An IRA cannot buy pre-IPO shares or startup equity from the owner, though it can buy the same type of asset from an unrelated party.

Investors seeking the official definitions can review the IRS guidance on prohibited transactions.

Understanding UBIT: The Tax Trap Self-Directed Investors Must Know

Retirement accounts are designed to shelter investment income, not business income. When an IRA earns business income, it may owe unrelated business income tax, known as UBIT or UBTI, at rates that top out at 37%.

Most common private real estate income is exempt. According to Sorensen, that includes:

  • Capital gains, whether short-term or long-term
  • Interest income from private lending or credit funds
  • Rental income from real estate
  • Dividends from C corporations
  • Royalty income, such as mineral rights or intellectual property

Sorensen identified two areas where investors most often run into UBIT. The first is an IRA holding an interest in an operating business structured as a pass-through, such as an LLC taxed as a partnership. Business profits flow to the IRA on a K-1, and the IRA must file Form 990-T and pay the tax. He described a client in a SaaS company that began distributing profits years after the investment. Those distributions triggered UBIT, but the much larger gain when the company was acquired was capital gain and exempt.

The second is frequent flipping or development. An IRA can flip a few properties a year as investment activity. An IRA flipping a property every month, holding each for less than a year, may look to the IRS like it is in the real estate business.

For investors with significant development or operating-business exposure, a blocker corporation can change the math. Sorensen described a client with a Roth IRA of roughly $600 million, built largely through real estate development. That Roth account owns an LLC taxed as a C corporation, which pays the 21% corporate rate. What remains reaches the Roth as dividends, which are exempt from UBIT, rather than as business income taxed at up to 37%.

Sorensen was careful to note that most investors do not need this structure. Many development deals can be organized so that investors receive long-term capital gains, and the blocker adds cost that only makes sense at scale. He also noted a related tax, UDFI, which can apply when an IRA uses debt financing.

Contribution Limits, Roth IRAs, and the Case for Roth Conversions

There is no cap on how large a self-directed account can grow. The limits apply to contributions. For 2026, the IRS IRA contribution limit is $7,500, or $8,600 for investors age 50 and older.

Self-directed custodians can also hold HSAs, custodial Roth IRAs for children, and other account types. Roth IRAs are the most popular account at Directed IRA, and high earners who exceed income limits can use the backdoor Roth strategy: a non-deductible traditional contribution followed by a conversion.

The difference between the two main account types comes down to timing:

Traditional vs. Roth IRA tax treatment comparison: contributions, growth, and withdrawals

Sorensen called himself “a Roth guy” and walked through the math on conversion. Suppose a 46-year-old holds $100,000 in a traditional IRA that grows to $1 million by age 66. At a combined 30% federal and state rate in retirement, roughly $300,000 goes to taxes on the way out. Converting today means reporting the $100,000 as income now, paying roughly $30,000, and letting the full balance grow tax-free afterward.

“I’d rather pay tax on the seed, the smaller amount, than on the harvest.”

The conversion is painful in the year it happens. For investors with a long horizon and high-growth private investments, however, the tradeoff can meaningfully improve after-tax outcomes.

How Financial Advisors Should Approach Self-Directed IRA Requests

For many advisors, a client asking to invest retirement funds in private real estate or crypto creates friction. Sorensen acknowledged that self-directed investing involves more work. Private investments require sourcing, paperwork, and due diligence, rather than a ticker entered on a phone.

Yet he noted that advisors serving ultra-high-net-worth clients already allocate heavily to private assets. For investors with conviction, his advice is to bring the advisor along rather than abandon the idea.

He shared the story of an anesthesiologist in Tucson who wanted his IRA to own 5% of a new surgery center alongside other physicians. The client told his advisor he would leave if the advisor did not help. The advisor met with Sorensen, learned the process, and completed the deal using roughly 10% of the client’s retirement assets.

The investment performed well. Just as important, the client told every doctor he knew. According to Sorensen, that advisor now has more than 100 accounts with Directed IRA and called the deal the best marketing he had ever done.

“Not one of my clients will say, here’s the publicly traded assets that I’m invested into. They’re not excited about that.”

Sorensen also recognized why many advisors hesitate. Their training centers on protecting principal, and a 5% return is far easier to accept than a loss. His recommendation for advisors balances both views: keep the allocation to a portion of the account, analyze the investment carefully, and evaluate the sponsor’s track record.

When developing a thorough diligence process, advisors can benefit from valuable insights on due diligence standards for real estate sponsors, as well as effective partnership with RIAs.

How Self-Directed IRA Investors Can Access Private Real Estate Funds

The profile of the typical self-directed investor is changing. Historically, most clients found their own deals: a friends-and-family partnership, a small apartment building, or a local rental.

Sorensen estimated that about 40% of Directed IRA accounts now invest in private funds, many of them raising $100 million or more. These funds serve the mass-affluent investor who wants diversification beyond the stock market but lacks the time or network to source individual deals.

For investors interested in multifamily real estate, that means evaluating fund strategy, market, business plan, and sponsor execution with the same rigor as any other allocation.

The Future of Retirement Capital and Private Markets

Sorensen sees two trends reshaping how retirement capital is invested.

The first is the rise of private funds built for individual investors. Rather than sourcing their own deals, more self-directed investors are choosing among multifamily, self-storage, distressed, and commercial funds based on where they have conviction.

The second is coming from Washington. President Trump’s executive order on alternative assets aims to make private investments more accessible inside 401(k) plans, where layers of employers, recordkeepers, platforms, and ERISA rules have historically limited access. Sorensen noted that the number of publicly traded U.S. companies has fallen by about half since the 1990s, while ultra-high-net-worth investors have steadily moved toward private markets.

Taken together, he expects more private fund opportunities for IRA investors and a gradual shift of 401(k) dollars into private assets.

Throughout the conversation, one theme remained consistent. The structure of an investment can matter as much as the investment itself. Choosing the right custodian, account type, entity structure, and tax treatment can shape long-term outcomes for accredited investors, financial advisors, and family offices.

Sorensen summarized the purpose of self-directed accounts plainly.

“Let your retirement account invest in the best investment asset you can find. That’s going to grow your account to be the largest balance when you hit 59.5 and you want to rely on it.”

As private markets continue to grow, the investors and advisors who create the greatest long-term value will be those who pair disciplined due diligence with a clear understanding of the rules. That principle reflects Viking Capital’s investment philosophy: preserving principal begins with disciplined execution through every market cycle.

Self-Directed IRAs: Frequently Asked Questions for Investors and Advisors

What is a self-directed IRA?

A self-directed IRA is a traditional, Roth, SEP, or other IRA held with a custodian that allows private and alternative investments. The account type and tax treatment stay the same. Only the provider and the range of permitted investments change.

Can I use my IRA to invest in real estate?

Yes. Federal law allows IRAs to own real estate, private funds, private companies, and other alternative assets. Many large brokerages simply do not offer those options, so investors need a self-directed custodian.

How do I move my existing IRA or 401(k) into a self-directed IRA?

An existing IRA can be transferred to a self-directed IRA of the same type with no tax or penalty. A 401(k) from a former employer can generally be rolled over. Funds in a current employer’s plan are often restricted until the plan’s retirement age, commonly 55 or 59½.

Do I need an LLC to invest my IRA in a private real estate fund?

Usually not. According to Mat Sorensen, an IRA can invest directly in a private fund, and an LLC adds cost and complexity. An IRA LLC is more useful for investors buying individual properties or doing frequent private lending.

What is a checkbook control IRA?

It is an IRA that owns 100% of an LLC managed by the account owner. The LLC has its own bank account, which lets the owner sign contracts, send earnest money, and manage rental income and expenses directly.

What can a self-directed IRA not invest in?

IRAs cannot hold life insurance, most collectibles, or S corporation stock. Certain gold, silver, platinum, and palladium are permitted when stored with an approved depository.

What is a prohibited transaction?

A prohibited transaction is a deal between the IRA and a disqualified person, including the account owner, a spouse, children, or parents. For example, an IRA cannot buy a property the owner already holds or sell an asset to a family member.

What is UBIT, and does it apply to real estate?

UBIT is a tax on business income earned inside an IRA, with rates up to 37%. Rental income, capital gains, interest, dividends, and royalties are generally exempt. UBIT most often applies to pass-through operating businesses or very frequent property flipping.

What is a blocker corporation in a self-directed IRA?

A blocker is a C corporation, often an LLC taxed as one, placed between the IRA and a business or development investment. The blocker pays the 21% corporate rate, and the IRA receives dividends that are exempt from UBIT. Sorensen recommends it only for larger development or operating-business investments.

How much can I contribute to a self-directed IRA in 2026?

The 2026 IRA contribution limit is $7,500, or $8,600 for investors age 50 and older. There is no limit on how large the account can grow through investment returns.

Should I convert my traditional IRA to a Roth IRA?

It depends on your tax bracket, time horizon, and ability to pay the tax from outside the account. A conversion is taxed as income in the year it occurs, but future growth and qualified withdrawals are tax-free. Sorensen favors Roth accounts for long-horizon, high-growth investments.

How should advisors handle client requests to self-direct?

Sorensen recommends limiting the allocation to a portion of the account, analyzing each investment carefully, and reviewing the sponsor’s track record. Advisors should also confirm compliance requirements before recommending investments outside their approved platform.

Interested in learning how leading investors and advisors are approaching self-directed IRAs, private real estate, alternative investments, and tax-efficient portfolio construction? Watch the full episode, explore more Wealth Unfiltered insights and conversations, and connect with Mat Sorensen’s team at DirectedIRA.com. Advisors and allocators can also learn how Viking Capital partners with RIAs, family offices, and institutional partners, or review our latest multifamily market reports.

Share This Article

Subscribe

Subscribe to receive the latest articles and podcasts about multifamily investing insights, industry news, and market trends.

By filling out this form, you consent to receive emails from Viking Capital Investments.

This article is intended for informational and educational purposes only and is not intended to provide, and should not be relied on, for investment, tax, legal, or accounting advice. The information is provided as of the date indicated and is subject to change without notice. Viking Capital does not have any obligation to update the information contained herein. Certain information presented or relied upon in this article may come from third-party sources. We do not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information and may receive incorrect information from third-party providers. All tax strategies discussed herein involve complex rules and regulations. Investors should consult with qualified tax, legal, and financial advisors before implementing any strategy.

Recent Articles